Abcg2a is the functional homolog of human ABCG2 expressed at the zebrafish blood–brain barrier

Background A principal protective component of the mammalian blood–brain barrier (BBB) is the high expression of the multidrug efflux transporters P-glycoprotein (P-gp, encoded by ABCB1) and ABCG2 (encoded by ABCG2) on the lumenal surface of endothelial cells. The zebrafish P-gp homolog Abcb4 is expressed at the BBB and phenocopies human P-gp. Comparatively little is known about the four zebrafish homologs of the human ABCG2 gene: abcg2a, abcg2b, abcg2c, and abcg2d. Here we report the functional characterization and brain tissue distribution of zebrafish ABCG2 homologs. Methods To determine substrates of the transporters, we stably expressed each in HEK-293 cells and performed cytotoxicity and fluorescent efflux assays with known ABCG2 substrates. To assess the expression of transporter homologs, we used a combination of RNAscope in situ hybridization probes and immunohistochemistry to stain paraffin-embedded sections of adult and larval zebrafish. Results We found Abcg2a had the greatest substrate overlap with ABCG2, and Abcg2d appeared to be the least functionally similar. We identified abcg2a as the only homolog expressed at the adult and larval zebrafish BBB, based on its localization to claudin-5 positive brain vasculature. Conclusions These results demonstrate the conserved function of zebrafish Abcg2a and suggest that zebrafish may be an appropriate model organism for studying the role of ABCG2 at the BBB. Supplementary Information The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12987-024-00529-5.


Introduction
The blood-brain barrier (BBB) refers to the specialized protective adaptations of the brain microvasculature, posing a significant impediment to the delivery of therapeutics to the brain [15].Brain endothelial cells play a prominent role at the BBB, as they form tight junctions that prevent paracellular transport, thus constituting a physical barrier to compounds.They also express ATPbinding cassette (ABC) transporters that act as a chemical barrier by actively transporting compounds back into the blood supply, therefore limiting brain penetration [21].P-glycoprotein (P-gp, encoded by the ABCB1 gene) and ABCG2 (encoded by the ABCG2 gene) are the most highly expressed ABC transporters at the mammalian BBB.Knockout mouse models have consistently demonstrated the important role played by P-gp and ABCG2 at the BBB in limiting the brain penetration of therapeutics [2].For example, eight hours after oral administration of 10 mg/kg of the janus kinase (JAK) 1 and 2 inhibitor momelotinib, the brain concentration was 3.1-fold, 6.5fold, and 48.4-fold higher in mice deficient in Abcb1a/b, Abcg2 or Abcb1a/b;Abcg2 compared to wild-type mice, respectively [5].Several targeted therapies are known to be restricted from the brain due to ABC transporter overexpression, as demonstrated by knockout mouse models [13].However, mouse models have certain limitations relative to zebrafish, such as greater cost, lower throughput and more challenging imaging [25].
Given its small size and amenability to higher throughput assays, the zebrafish has been suggested as a suitable in vivo model of the BBB.However, little is known about the role of ABC transporters at the zebrafish BBB.Zebrafish express 2 homologs of human ABCB1, termed abcb4 and abcb5 [6].While early studies with the anti-P-gp antibody C219 suggested that a zebrafish homolog of P-gp was expressed in brain capillaries [7,29], the epitope for the C219 antibody is present in both zebrafish homologs of P-gp [7].We subsequently showed that Abcb4 is the sole P-gp homolog expressed at the zebrafish BBB and found that the substrate specificity of Abcb4 completely overlaps with that of P-gp, while Abcb5 confers resistance to a slightly narrower range of tested substrates [19].Much less work has been done to characterize the zebrafish homologs of ABCG2.
Zebrafish have 4 direct homologs of the human ABCG2 gene-abcg2a, abcg2b, abcg2c and abcg2d-yet relatively little is known about the function or expression of the transporters [3].Tsinkalovsky and colleagues hypothesized that an ABCG2-related gene was expressed in cells extracted from zebrafish kidney marrow, which serves a similar function as the bone marrow in mammals, based on the discovery of a side population of cells that accumulated low levels of Hoechst 33342, a fluorescent ABCG2 and P-gp substrate [26].This side population could be abolished by the addition of reserpine or fumitremorgin C (FTC), both of which are known to inhibit ABCG2-mediated transport [26].These observations were extended by Kobayashi et al., who isolated side population cells and found expression of both abcg2a and abcg2c [11].To determine which was responsible for transport of Hoechst 33342, they transfected cells with either gene and found that abcg2a overexpression resulted in decreased Hoechst 33342 retention [11].Additionally, expression of abcg2a and abcg2b was found to be high in the intestine, while abcg2c expression was high in the head kidney, body kidney, spleen, intestine and gills, and abcg2d was not detected in any of the tissues examined [11].Given the paucity of data, we determined that a thorough investigation of the zebrafish homologs of human ABCG2 was needed.We hypothesized that an ABCG2 homolog is present at the zebrafish BBB.We therefore sought to determine which ABCG2 homologs are expressed at the zebrafish BBB and compare the substrate specificity of the various homologs to that of human ABCG2.

Zebrafish housing and husbandry
Zebrafish (Danio rerio) wild-type strain TAB5 were housed with a 14-h/10-h light/dark cycle with a water temperature of 28.5 °C in a recirculating aquatic system.Zebrafish husbandry and embryonic staging was conducted as previously described [31].Zebrafish embryos were raised in an incubator at 28.5 °C in Instant Ocean (Blacksburg, VA) (60 mg/L DI water) and were euthanized at 7 days post-fertilization.All animal studies were compliant with the National Cancer Institute-Bethesda Animal Care and Use Committee approved study protocol (LCB-033-2).

Immunoblot
Total cell lysates were extracted from transfected HEK-293 cells using RIPA buffer and incubated at 37 °C for 20 min.Lysates (30 μg protein) were resolved by gel electrophoresis on a NuPAGE ™ 4-12% Bis-Tris gel (Invitrogen, Waltham, MA) and then transferred to a nitrocellulose membrane.The membrane was blocked in 5% non-fat milk in PBST (0.1% Tween 20) for 1 h at room temperature, then probed overnight with our custom rabbit polyclonal anti-Abcg2a antibody (diluted 1:5000) and rabbit monoclonal anti-beta actin (diluted 1:2000) while rocking at 4 °C.The primary antibody was detected by incubating the membrane with IRDye ® 680RD goat anti-rabbit IgG Secondary Antibody (LI-COR, Lincoln, NE, RRID:AB_10956166), and measuring the fluorescence using the LiCor ODYSSEY CLx membrane scanner (RRID:SCR_014579).

Flow cytometry
Flow cytometry efflux assays with fluorescent human ABCG2 substrates were based on those previously described [20].Briefly, trypsinized cells were plated and incubated with fluorescent substrates (5 µM pheophorbide a or 5 µM mitoxantrone) in the presence or absence of ABCG2 inhibitors (10 µM KS176, 10 µM Ko143, 10 µM elacridar, 10 µM tariquidar) at 37 °C for 30 min.The medium was removed, and cells were incubated in media in the presence or absence of inhibitors for 1 h.Cells were then washed and re-suspended in ice-cold PBS prior to analysis using a FACSCanto II flow cytometer (BD Biosciences San Jose, CA, RRID:SCR_018055) and data were then analyzed with FlowJo software (v 10.8.1, Tree Star, Inc, Ashland, OR, RRID:SCR_008520).Pheophorbide a and mitoxantrone fluorescence was detected with a 635-nm red diode laser and a 670-nm filter.At least 10,000 events were collected for each sample.Samples incubated with fluorescent substrates without inhibitors are defined as the 'efflux' histogram, and unstained cell samples are the control cell autofluorescence histogram.

Cytotoxicity assays
Trypsinized cells were plated at 5,000 cells/well in white opaque 96-well plates and allowed to adhere overnight.Drugs were then added, with each concentration tested in triplicate, and cells were incubated for 72 h.Cell growth was assessed using the CellTiter-Glo (Promega, Madison, WI) reagent, according to the manufacturer's instructions.Luminescence was measured on a Tecan Infinite M200 Pro microplate reader (Tecan Group, Morrisville, NC, RRID:SCR_019033).50% growth inhibition (GI 50 ) values were calculated at the drug concentration at which 50% luminescence was observed in comparison to untreated cells.Relative resistance (RR) values are the ratio of the GI 50 values of the transporter transfected versus the empty vector-transfected HEK-293 cells.

Immunofluorescence and RNAScope probes
Adult zebrafish were euthanized by immersion in a lethal dose of tricaine methanesulfonate for 30 min, prior to fixation in 10% neutral buffered formalin (NBF) for 24 h at room temperature.Larvae were anesthetized using tricaine methanesulfonate and euthanized via rapid chilling (hypothermic shock), prior to fixation in 10% NBF for 24 h at room temperature.Zebrafish were incubated in 0.5 M EDTA (pH 8) at room temperature for 7 days with gentle agitation.Before embedding and processing, zebrafish were washed twice with nuclease-free PBS.Paraffin-embedded samples were processed as previously described [19].Briefly, coronal and transverse sections were cut from the paraffin block at 5 µm and placed on positively charged slides for RNA in situ hybridization (ISH) (RNAscope) and immunohistochemistry (IHC).
The degree of the sequence homology was color coded corresponding to EMBL-EBI Clustal Multiple Sequence Alignment consensus symbols.Fully conserved residues (EBI symbol * (asterisk)) are colored black; conserved residues with strongly similar properties (EBI symbol: (colon)), approximately equivalent to scoring > 0.5 in the Gonnet PAM 250 matrix, are colored green; residues with weakly similar properties (EBI symbol.(period)), approximately equivalent to scoring≤0.5 and > 0 in the Gonnet PAM 250 matrix are colored yellow, and nonconservative substitutions are depicted with red color.

Characterization of HEK-293 cells stably expressing zebrafish Abcg2a-d
Human embryonic kidney (HEK-293) cells were stably transfected to express an empty vector, or a vector containing human ABCG2, zebrafish abcg2a, abcg2b, abcg2c, or abcg2d.Zebrafish gene constructs included a 5' FLAG tag sequence to enable protein immunodetection, as there are no commercially available antibodies that cross-react with any zebrafish ABCG2 homologs.Positive FLAG staining was observed in Abcg2a-d-expressing cell pellets (Fig. 1A).RNAscope probe positive signal was observed only in the corresponding transfected cell line, demonstrating specific detection of abcg2a-d homologs (Fig. 1B).The level of RNAscope probe staining was comparable among samples, indicating a similar level of mRNA expression among the corresponding cell lines.The typical punctate staining pattern seen in RNAscope probe images is not observed here due to the high signal density.

Zebrafish Abcg2 homologs can efflux fluorescent ABCG2 substrates
We assessed the ability of Abcg2a-d homolog-expressing cells to efflux the fluorescent ABCG2 substrates mitoxantrone and pheophorbide a.Cells were incubated with 5 µM mitoxantrone or pheophorbide a in the absence or presence of 10 µM of the ABCG2 inhibitors KS176, Ko143, elacridar or tariquidar, and flow cytometry was used to measure intracellular fluorescence.When coincubated with inhibitors, ABCG2-expressing cells exhibit an increase in intracellular fluorescence evidenced by a shift to the right of histograms corresponding to the inhibitors compared to uninhibited efflux peaks, with little overlap between the histograms (Fig. 3).There was a rightward inhibited peak shift for Abcg2a with mitoxantrone, and to a greater extent with pheophorbide a, indicating Abcg2a can efflux both substrates.Pheophorbide a also appears to be a substrate for Abcg2b and Abcg2c.Neither mitoxantrone nor pheophorbide a were transported by Abcg2d, indicated by the overlay of the efflux and inhibited histograms.In addition to substrate specificities, these data also show all 4 ABCG2 inhibitors were able to inhibit Abcg2a, Abcg2b and Abg2c.

Abcg2a-d homology modelling
Despite the fact Abcg2d is the homolog with second highest amino acid identity to human ABCG2 (Additional file 6: Table S2), it has the least substrate overlap.To seek insights into differences in substrate specificity between ABCG2 and Abcg2a-d paralogs, we employed homology modeling techniques.We aligned predicted 3-D structures of Abcg2a-d to cryo-EM structures of ABCG2 bound to the substrate drugs topotecan or mitoxantrone (Additional file 1: Fig. S1), focusing on the putative drug binding pocket (Additional file 2: Fig. S2), and color-coded amino acid residues based on their level of conservation.As expected, based on total amino acid identity and our functional data, the drug binding pocket of Abcg2a exhibited the highest conservation to ABCG2.
In contrast, the drug binding pocket of Abcg2b and Abcg2c displayed the greatest differences and Abcg2d presented an intermediate level of conservation.

abcg2a is expressed at the adult zebrafish blood-brain barrier
Since ABCG2 is highly expressed at the mammalian BBB, we hypothesized that one or more of the ABCG2 homologs would localize to the adult zebrafish brain.Positive staining for abcg2a RNA was observed in adult brain sections, evidenced by a punctate signal which localized to the vasculature (Fig. 4).No positive staining was observed for abcg2b or abcg2c in the brain.Low levels of abcg2d staining were observed in the brain parenchyma, but the transporter was not localized to the vasculature.No differences were observed between brain regions or between males and females.To determine if the vasculature where abcg2a localized had BBB properties, we co-stained with the endothelial tight junction protein claudin-5, a canonical marker of the BBB, using an antibody that cross-reacts with mammalian and zebrafish claudin-5 homologs [1].The positive signal for abcg2a co-localized with claudin-5   positive vasculature, indicating it is expressed at the adult zebrafish BBB (Fig. 5).The zebrafish P-gp homolog abcb4, which we previously determined is expressed at the zebrafish BBB [19], also localized to the same claudin-5 positive vessels as abcg2a.

Abcg2a and Abcb4 are co-expressed at the blood-brain barrier
There are no commercially available antibodies that cross-react with Abcg2a, so we generated a custom antibody and validated its specificity (Additional file 3: Fig. S3).The commercial antibody C219, which recognizes human and murine P-gp, cross-reacts with the zebrafish P-gp homologs Abcb4 and Abcb5.We previously confirmed using RNAscope probes that the positive C219 signal in the brain vasculature corresponds to Abcb4 expression [19].In sequential adult brain sections, we observed positive staining with Abcg2a and C219 antibodies in claudin-5 positive vasculature throughout the brain.(Fig. 6).This confirms the co-expression of Abcg2a and Abcb4 protein at the adult zebrafish BBB.

abcg2a is expressed at the developing larval blood-brain barrier
The zebrafish BBB begins to form between 1 and 3 days post fertilization (dpf ) and becomes progressively restrictive until 10 dpf [7,28].We therefore sought to determine if any abcg2 paralogs localized to the developing larval BBB.At 5 dpf we detected abcg2a localized to claudin-5 positive brain vasculature (Fig. 7A), and found that abcg2a and abcb4 both localize to claudin-5 positive brain vasculature (Fig. 7B).In concordance with our adult staining, abcg2b, abcg2c and abcg2d do not localize to the larval brain vasculature.At 7 dpf, as with 5 dpf larvae, abcg2a localized to claudin-5 positive brain vasculature (Additional file 4: Fig. S4).Sex is not differentiated in 5 or 7 dpf larvae and therefore cannot be investigated as a variable.

Discussion
Here we report our characterization of the function and brain distribution of the zebrafish homologs of ABCG2.We used stably-transfected HEK-293 cells as a model to study the function of each of the zebrafish Abcg2 homologs in isolation, and a panel of 8 substrates and 4 inhibitors of ABCG2 in cytotoxicity and fluorescent efflux assays.We found that Abcg2a had the greatest substrate overlap with ABCG2 and was able to transport all assayed ABCG2 substrates.Abcg2d appeared to be the most divergent from ABCG2 and had the lowest GI 50 for 4 out of the 6 cytotoxic substrates and did not efflux either fluorescent substrate.We expected Abcg2a to be the most similar to ABCG2, given the fact it has the highest amino acid homology (61.4%,Additional file 6: Table S2), effluxes Hoechst 33342, as does ABCG2, and is inhibited by verapamil, which can inibit ABCG2 at very high concentrations [11].It was surprising to us that Abcg2d appeared to be the least functionally similar to ABCG2, as it has the second highest amino acid homology (57.4%) to ABCG2 and was predicted based on synteny to be the most direct homolog of ABCG2 [3].Our homology modelling did demonstrate that Abcg2d had a more divergent substrate binding pocket than Abcg2a compared to ABCG2.These variations in the structure of the drug binding pocket could help elucidate the differences in substrate specificity observed among Abcg2 homologs.Thus, we found that all 4 zebrafish homologs were able to transport select ABCG2 substrates to varying degrees and that the substrate profile of Abcg2a is most similar to human ABCG2.Overall, the ABCG2 substrates we assayed seem to be weaker substrates for the zebrafish homologs, evidenced by the lower GI 50 values in cytotoxicity assays compared to ABCG2 (Fig. 2, Additional file 5: Table S1), and the less pronounced peak shift between the uninhibited and inhibited conditions in fluorescent efflux assays (Fig. 3).The only exception to this was in the case of gedatolisib, which was transported slightly more efficiently by Abcg2b (GI 50 4.06 ± 1.46 μM) than ABCG2 (GI 50 3.84 ± 1.53 μM).The ABCG2 inhibitors KS176, Ko143, elacridar and tariquidar were all able to inhibit Abcg2a, -b and -c, at the same concentration used with ABCG2 (10 μM).It is unknown if they inhibit Abcg2d, and this will need to be assessed with additional fluorescent substrates, or in cytotoxicity assays with identified Abcg2d substrates.Some human P-gp inhibitors are less effective against the zebrafish homologs Abcb4 and Abcb5 in the case of select substrates.For example, the P-gp (and ABCG2) inhibitor elacridar was less effective than the P-gp inhibitor valspodar at inhibiting Abcb4 and Abcb5 rhodamine 123 transport [19].Our data suggest that all 4 inhibitors are similarly effective at inhibiting the Abcg2ac transport of pheophorbide a, evidenced by the overlay of histograms corresponding to inhibitors (Fig. 3).A wider range of ABCG2 substrates and varying inhibitor concentrations are needed to assess substrate-specific inhibitor efficacy for zebrafish Abcg2 paralogs.One reasonable hypothesis is that the zebrafish Abcg2 paralogs have evolved to recognize toxic materials in the marine environment, and/or zebrafish-specific metabolites and therefore their drug specificities differ somewhat from human ABCG2.
Expression of zebrafish ABC transporters in mammalian cells is a tractable method to assess their function in isolation; however, it also comes with the caveat that zebrafish proteins may not function in these heterologous expression systems as they do in vivo in zebrafish.Fluorescent ABCG2 substrates could be administered in vivo to zebrafish larvae in the presence or absence of inhibitors in conjunction with fluorescent microscopy to confirm if they are Abcg2 substrates, as has been done for zebrafish Abcb4 with rhodamine 123 and calcein-AM [6].
Zebrafish abcg2a was the only homolog expressed at the BBB in adult and larval zebrafish.Abcg2a and Abcb4, expressed in claudin-5 positive vasculature in the adult brain, likely represent the relevant ABCG2 and P-gp homologs at the zebrafish BBB.This suggests they may function in concert to protect the brain parenchyma, as they do in mammals.In humans, an analysis of transporter density by brain region (normalized by vascular density) showed P-gp density is 9% lower in gray versus white matter, and is lower in the parietal cortex (19%), temporal cortex (15%) and hippocampus (17%) relative to the thalamus; and ABCG2 did not vary by brain region but was 33% higher in gray versus white matter [9].We did not observe any differences in the distribution of Abcb4 or Abcg2a in gray versus white matter or by brain region, although quantification may reveal differences indistinguishable by a pathologist's eye.One of the major species differences between the human and rodent BBB is the higher expression of both P-gp and ABCG2 homologs in rodents [27], resulting in a higher brain to plasma ratio of P-gp substrates in humans [24].Quantification of transporter levels at the zebrafish BBB has not yet been reported.Also, the subcellular localization of Abcb4 and Abcg2a has not been determined, but the increase of brain to vascular ratio of Abcb4 substrates upon transporter inhibition and knockout is consistent with luminal expression [10,17].
It will be interesting to determine at what developmental stage abcg2a and abcb4 localize to the BBB, as this will inform the utility of larval zebrafish for BBB studies.We detected abcg2a and abcb4 at the BBB of 5 dpf larvae, although the expression of both has been reported from 24 h post fertilization (hpf ) in a BBB vasculature subcluster (hema.28vasculature blood-brain barrier) from whole-embryo single-cell sequencing [22,23].At 5 dpf, the most mature age represented in the dataset of Sur and colleagues, abcg2a and abcb4 are the first and second most highly expressed ABC transporters in the BBB subcluster, indicating they may be the predominant, but not the only, ABC transporters expressed.
In conclusion, we have shown that zebrafish ABCG2 homologs are functionally conserved, with Abcg2a appearing to be most similar to ABCG2.The localization of Abcg2a to the BBB and its substrate and inhibitor overlap with ABCG2 indicate that the zebrafish has potential utility for the study of Abcg2 activity at the BBB.Our data, and the literature, demonstrate functional similarities between Abcg2a and ABCG2, and Abcb4 and P-gp, giving credence to the idea that the zebrafish could be a relevant model system to assess the brain penetration of substrate drugs [6,11,19].

Fig. 2
Fig. 2 Zebrafish ABCG2 homologs confer resistance to cytotoxic ABCG2 substrates.HEK-293 cells stably expressing empty vector, ABCG2 or Abcg2a-d were treated with known cytotoxic ABCG2 substrates for 3 days.GI 50 and relative resistance values are summarized in Additional file 5: TableS1

Fig. 3
Fig. 3 Zebrafish ABCG2 homologs differentially efflux fluorescent ABCG2 substrates.HEK293 cells overexpressing empty vector (EV), ABCG2 or Abcg2a-d were treated with the fluorescent ABCG2 substrates mitoxantrone and pheophorbide a in the absence or presence of the ABCG2 inhibitors KS176, Ko143, elacridar and tariquidar.Representative histograms are shown from at least 3 biological replicates of intracellular fluorescence measured by flow cytometry.The control condition (red) of untreated cells shows cell autofluorescence, and the efflux condition (blue) indicates cells treated with substrate without inhibitor

Fig. 4
Fig. 4 abcg2a is the only ABCG2 homolog detected in adult zebrafish brain vasculature.Paraffin-embedded adult zebrafish sections were stained with hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) probed with RNAscope probes (yellow) to detect abcg2a, abcg2b, abcg2c or abcg2d RNA, and DAPI (blue).Each punctate dot signal represents amplification of a single target RNA molecule.Sections shown are representative cross sections of the telencephalon and myelencephalon.Scale bar = 20 μm